Susie E II Charter Fishing Boat Blog

Susie E Hooks Record Porbeagle Shark

On September 23, 2014, the Susie E II reeled in a massive, 398 pound female Porbeagle Shark, the largest ever taken on the East End, and the third largest ever caught worldwide. This is a pending NYS record.

The three-man group that hired the boat that day had come out from New Jersey and up-Island for an all-day charter trip, and we had set up about 20 miles south of the Point.  We began the day tuna fishing, but we weren’t having much luck, so we set up for shark.  We had four baits out, and the shark hit the top one and took it all the way to the bottom.  For the next 45 minutes, she stayed down and we watched her swim along with the boat on the sonar machine, not taking any big runs like you might expect from a Mako or a Thresher.  A little less than an hour after we first hooked her, she came back up to the surface, and it was pretty much a tug of war to work her onto the boat.PrizeShark

We had no idea that we had hooked into a Porbeagle, because they are a rare species of shark that is usually found in the colder waters of Canada and Maine.  Adults also usually grow to about 300 pounds, so when we identified it and realized how big it was, we knew we had a once-in-a-lifetime fish on our hands.

Back at the dock the shark weighed out at a little less than 400lbs, an absolute monster for this breed of shark.  The all-tackle world record is 507lbs, and the next biggest is in the 400’s. This is the third largest Porbeagle ever caught on rod and reel, and we have submitted all the paperwork to the New York State DEC to certify the catch.

The Porbeagle Shark is a rare visitor to the Montauk fishery.  A relentless predator, the shark is distributed across the temperate regions of the globe, ranging from Newfoundland to Morocco in the North Atlantic.  Typically weighing up to 300lbs, the porbeagle is powerfully built, with a barrel-shaped body, a long pointed snout, and five pairs of prominent gill slits, along with a distinctive white blotch on the bottom of its dorsal fin.  September to November is their mating season, and their delicious meat is among the most valuable and highly-sought after of any shark.

The guys who chartered the boat had us clean and cut up all that sharkmeat for them to take home.  Since they recognized that this was a once-in-a-lifetime catch for the Susie E, they were nice enough to let us have the tail, dorsal fins and the head, which will be mounted and displayed at our berth at Westlake Marina.

Montauk Fishing Report – September 15 2014

Montauk Fishing Report – September

IMG_20140701_123750_546It’s September in Montauk, and that means the shark fishing is heating up. In the past couple of weeks we have already had some very decent shark fishing. This is only going to get better as the annual Mako and Thresher migrations come through. In the last month, we took over 30 sharks on the Susie E, with most of them weighing in at the 150-250 pound range. This is a very good sign, and we’ll be hunting monster sharks well into the fall.

It has been a similar story for the stripers. We had a blazing hot spring and early summer Striped Bass season on the Susie E: big catches with lots of fish in the 30-40+ pound range. We experienced the usual late summer slowdown in August, but now that September is here the bite is picking up again. We’re looking ahead to some excellent bass fishing as the weather turns cooler and the fall migration comes through.

Sea Bass and Porgies have been holding up well, too. And the Fluke fishing has been particularly solid for this time of year. We must have taken a few hundred Fluke in the last few weeks, many of them up to 10 pounds.

Fall is a perfect time for fishing in Montauk. Get in touch and we’ll get you out on the water and into some fish.


Montauk Cod Fishing Report – February

This month the Montauk cod fishinghas been excellent when we can get out due to the weather.  The cod fishing in Montauk Point was solid right from the start of month as expected from  the last few seasons success.

Read more…

Susie E II Cod Fishing Report week ending February 7th, 2010

The hot Montauk cod bite continued this week and weather allowed us to get in three great trips, all full-boat limits!!!

Read more…

Montauk Cod Fishing is Hot! 2010 Season

Montauk Cod Fishing Is HOT!  If last year was great, this year promises to be even better!  We have been out even earlier this year and the action has been great!  Cod fishing in Montauk, New York, promises to be even better than last year!

Read more…

Montauk Fishing Report – November 11th, 2009

Montauk Black Fishing is Hot

The highlight of this month is the Blackfishing out in Montauk.  We are out just about every other day fishing for Montauk blackfish and have been doing well with fish to 10lbs.  We have not seen blackfish this good out in Montauk in many years and the blackfishing should continue strong over the next couple of weeks, well into December.  This is the time to cash in on these tough fighting toothy fish.

Read more…

Open Boat for Montauk Cod & Blackfish – Starting November 15th, 2009

The Codfish are already starting to show out in Montauk in some of our local spots.  As the water cools, more bait will be coming down and the big schools should move right in and the Montauk Codfishing season will be in full swing.

Read more…

Montauk Fishing Report – July 17th, 2009

The last two weeks have been fantastic out in the Mecca.  Let’s start with the sharkin!

Read more…

Montauk Fishing Report – June 24th, 2009

Montauk Striped Bass fishing has been good, the big fish have finally moved in.  There is a huge body of new stripers that are between 20-35lbs so it is a great time to get out for our spring striper run.

Read more…

New Montauk Fishing Blog

Welcome To Our New Montauk Fishing Blog – 6/10/09

We have just launched a new website for the Susie E and would love to hear what you think.  Our new site will provide updates on Montauk fishing, techniques and everything related to our Montauk Sportfishing community.

Read more…